Waterfront Estates and Land for Sale and Rent on One of The Bahamas’ Most Peaceful and Historic Islands
- All Listings
- Under $100,000
- $100,000 - $200,000
- $200,000 - $300,000
- $300,000 - $400,000
- $400,000 - $500,000
- $500,000 - $600,000
- $600,000 - $700,000
- $700,000 - $800,000
- $800,000 - $900,000
- $900,000 - $1,000,000
- Over $1,000,000
Discover Life in Cat Island
Cat Island is one of The Bahamas’ quietest and most naturally beautiful islands. It’s known for its laid-back pace, friendly community, and deep sense of history. This is where Sir Sidney Poitier spent his early years, and where the past still lingers in the ruins of old manor homes and Loyalist settlements.
The island is full of lush greenery and uncrowded beaches that stretch for miles. People come here for the peace and the space, and they stay for the simple, down-to-earth lifestyle that makes Cat Island feel like home.
What makes Cat Island stand out:
-
Home to Mount Alvernia, the highest point in The Bahamas
-
A deep-rooted cultural heritage with historic ruins and quiet settlements
-
Long, unspoiled beaches are perfect for solitude and reflection
-
A laid-back, self-sufficient, nature-focused lifestyle far from major crowds
-
Small-scale resorts and eco-friendly stays like Fernandez Bay Village
-
Ideal for fishing, diving, and outdoor exploration
-
Accessible via New Bight Airport with scheduled flights from Nassau
Cat Island Real Estate Market: Homes for Sale and Rent
Cat Island’s real estate market is unlike any other in The Bahamas: quiet, boutique, and rich with history. The island is home to some of the nation’s highest elevations, with Mount Alvernia rising to 206 feet.
From hilltop parcels offering rare 360° ocean views to waterfront lots tucked near historic enclaves like Port Royal, Castle Bluff, and Man-O-War Point, the island’s landscape is both striking and diverse. Buyers are drawn here for the natural beauty, privacy, and timeless charm that define Cat Island living.
-
Average Sale Price: $1,003,333
-
Median Sale Price: $760,000
-
Price Range: $750,000 – $1,500,000
-
Property Types: Fishing Lodges, Single-Family Homes, Multi-Family Homes, Beachfront Homes, and Vacation Homes
-
Market Vibe: Scenic, private, and steeped in heritage, ideal for investors and buyers seeking off-grid luxury and timeless island appeal
Fishing Lodges
Fishing lodges on Cat Island are built to blend with their natural surroundings, often located near premier fishing grounds or diving areas. Properties like Hawks Nest Resort and Marina cater to outdoor enthusiasts and those looking for turnkey investment opportunities that support eco-tourism or sport fishing.
Single-Family Homes
These homes are either hilltop estates with panoramic 360° views or beachfront properties with direct ocean access. They are often owner-built and custom-designed, reflecting the island’s rustic charm. Historical influences are evident in the architecture, particularly in areas such as Port Royal and Castle Bluff.
Multi-Family Homes
Multi-family residences are relatively uncommon but do exist, primarily as guest lodges or as part of expanded family estates. They present opportunities for multi-generational living or short-term rentals, especially in central locations near the island’s airstrips or key beachfront areas.
Luxury and Resort‑Style Amenities on Cat Island
Cat Island doesn’t have sprawling resorts or high-rise hotels, but that’s exactly the point. The island’s few boutique retreats offer a more personal kind of luxury, where service feels like hospitality and the setting speaks for itself. It’s laid-back, scenic, and designed for people who want to unwind in nature without sacrificing comfort.
-
Hawks Nest Club: Tucked away on a quiet stretch of beach, Hawks Nest feels more like a private retreat than a resort. It has its own private airstrip, on-site dining, fishing charters, and guided excursions. It’s a favourite among boaters, pilots, and anyone who wants a full island experience without the crowds.
-
Fernandez Bay Village: For a classic Cat Island escape, Fernandez Bay Village holds all the charm. Think beachfront villas, a laid-back oceanfront bar and restaurant, an infinity pool, clubhouse, and direct access to snorkelling and diving. It has been a go-to for generations of travellers looking for something peaceful, familiar, and right by the sea.
-
Greenwood Beach Resort: Set along eight miles of untouched beach, Greenwood is the place to truly unplug. Guests stay in simple, breezy cottages and spend their days biking, beachcombing, or heading out on guided tours. It’s relaxed, low-key, and exactly what you’d hope to find on a quiet island like this.
Everything You Need, Minutes Away
Cat Island may be quiet and remote, but you can still find what you need without having to go far. Most essentials, like groceries, basic supplies, and clinics, are available in local hubs like New Bight and Arthur’s Town. You may not find big box stores or constant deliveries, so many people plan ahead, especially if they’re staying a while or visiting in the off-season.
Schools
Education on Cat Island is supported by several local institutions serving young learners in a close-knit, community-focused environment.
-
Orange Creek Primary: A centrally located school offering foundational education in a traditional Bahamian setting.
-
Old Bight Primary: A well-known school in the southern district, providing a structured academic environment for early learners.
Grocery Stores
While options are limited compared to larger islands, several stores provide daily staples, fresh produce, and household goods.
-
New Bight Food Market: A local go-to for groceries, snacks, and general provisions.
-
Alvernia Food Store: Conveniently situated near Mount Alvernia, it offers pantry basics and fresh items.
-
Orange Creek Inn Store: A small store offering essentials to guests and locals in the northern district.
H3: Restaurants
Cat Island’s food scene is casual and rooted in local flavour, with small eateries offering hearty Bahamian meals and island hospitality.
-
J & R's Restaurant: Known for its comfort food and welcoming vibe.
-
Da Pink Chicken: A local gem offering grilled dishes and authentic island flavours.
-
Lakeview Restaurant: A laid-back venue with outdoor seating and traditional Bahamian plates.
-
Sweet Tambrin: Offers homestyle meals and a cosy, family-run atmosphere.
Historic and Scenic Sights
Standing at 206 feet above sea level, Mount Alvernia is the highest point in The Bahamas and a defining feature of Cat Island’s landscape. At its summit lies The Hermitage, a hand-carved monastery built by Father Jerome in the early 20th century. It’s an easy hike to reach this historic stone retreat, where you can enjoy panoramic views of the island. It’s a popular spot for both locals and visitors who visit it for reflection, history, or simply a scenic hike.
Start searching for your dream home now.
When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.