Harbour Island, Bahamas Real Estate

Luxury Homes for Sale in One of The Bahamas’ Most Stylish Island Communities

• All Listings
• Under $100,000
• $700,000 - $800,000
• $800,000 - $900,000
• $900,000 - $1,000,000
• Over $1,000,000

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Price Range

Save Search

Sort by:

Price, high to low

$45,000,000

Juicy Hill, Eleuthera

6 Beds 7 Baths 12,000 SqFt Residential MLS® # 65234

$39,500,000

Crown Pigeon Island & Cay, Eleuthera

15 Beds 15 Baths 479,160 SqFt Residential MLS® # 66706

$18,400,000

↓ $2,100,000

Villa 2 Modern Estate Harbour Island, New Providence/Paradise Island

9 Beds 9.5 Baths 12,000 SqFt Residential MLS® # 5009058

$17,950,000

Buttonwood Estate, Eleuthera

5 Beds 6 Baths 23,235 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67764

$17,500,000

La Palmeraie Villa 1, Eleuthera

9 Beds 9 Baths 11,736 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67584

$16,950,000

Harbour Island Beachfront, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 140,133 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67375

$14,950,000

Sand Bank Beach Villa, Eleuthera

6 Beds 6 Baths 4,680 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67900

$9,990,000

↓ $4,010,000

Doll House, Eleuthera

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,300 SqFt Residential MLS® # 66012

$8,500,000

↓ $1,495,000

Java Estate, Eleuthera

9 Beds 8 Baths 16,327 SqFt Residential MLS® # 60027

$6,925,000

↓ $1,070,000

Lavender Hill, Eleuthera

2 Beds 2 Baths 2,400 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67095

$5,999,000

The Narrows, Eleuthera

4 Beds 4 Baths 5,151 SqFt Residential MLS® # 66289

$5,900,000

Crown Street, Eleuthera

2 Beds 2 Baths 2,660 SqFt Residential MLS® # 65817

1 2 3

Next

Discover Life in Harbour Island

Harbour Island is known for its pink-sand beaches, pastel cottages, and effortlessly stylish atmosphere. It feels upscale but not in a pretentious way. Here, golf carts outnumber cars, and polished beach bars sit next to local bakeries. The island is compact, easy to navigate, and full of charm. People come here for its beauty, but they stay for the sense of ease and community that’s hard to find anywhere else.

What makes Harbour Island stand out:

• Pink Sands Beach, which is world-famous but rarely crowded

• Walkable streets lined with pastel homes and blooming bougainvillea

• A close-knit community with a mix of locals, expats, and returning seasonal residents

• Golf carts are the main way to get around 

• Boutique dining, beach clubs, and stylish shops within minutes

• Strong local pride and preservation of heritage architecture

• Quick access to North Eleuthera Airport via a short water taxi ride

• Ideal for buyers seeking charm, comfort, and an easygoing, elegant lifestyle

Harbour Island Real Estate Market: Homes for Sale 

The real estate market in Harbour Island is small, selective, and high-end. It caters to buyers who want more than just a vacation home; they’re looking for something special. Properties here appeal to well-travelled families, retirees seeking refined island life, and investors drawn to the island’s prestige and limited inventory. 

With such high demand and relatively few listings, homes on Harbour Island tend to hold their value and offer long-term potential, both as personal retreats and income-generating rentals.

• Average Sale Price: $5,450,000

• Median Sale Price: $5,900,000

• Price Range: $1,500,000 - 8,950,000

• Property Types: Single Family Homes, Multi-Family Homes, Luxury Homes, Beachfront Homes, Vacation Homes

• Market Vibe: Boutique, with lasting appeal

Luxury Homes and Beachfront Estates

Harbour Island is best known for its high-end homes, many of which sit just steps from the beach. These properties often feature private pools, lush gardens, and open layouts that frame ocean views. Whether it’s a modern build or a historic cottage with high-end finishes, these homes are designed for comfort, privacy, and style.

Vacation Properties and Income Potential

Some buyers come to Harbour Island with investment in mind. There’s strong demand for short-term rentals, especially in walkable areas close to the beach and Dunmore Town. Homes that offer a balance of charm, amenities, and location can perform well on the rental market and give owners a chance to enjoy the property in between guests.

Everything You Need, Minutes Away

Harbour Island balances exclusive charm with practical convenience. Most residents fly into North Eleuthera Airport, followed by a quick water taxi transfer that lands you right in the heart of Dunmore Town. Once here, everyday essentials, from schools and groceries to great dining, are all easily accessible by golf cart or on foot, making this small island feel both intimate and comfortable.

Schools

Harbour Island has solid education options for residents and foreigners with school-going kids who plan to stay long term.

• The Green School: An independent school focused on experiential and environmentally conscious learning, currently serving students from Kindergarten to Junior High. It plans to expand into a complete K–12 in future.
  

• Harbour Island All Age School: A government-run school serving local students from primary through high school levels. It's the island’s main public educational institution.

Grocery Stores

Island grocery shopping is simple and accessible, with several locally owned stores offering everyday essentials.

• Park View Convenience:  Known for its fair prices and wide selection of household goods, school supplies, and produce. Located right in town for easy access. directory.conchandcoconut.com

• Pigly Wiggly: A well-known neighbourhood grocery store stocked with everyday items, pantry goods, and frozen foods.

• Captain Bob’s Marketplace: Offers a mix of groceries, snacks, and speciality items in a friendly, locally run environment.

• Kay Markets: Another convenient stop for basic groceries and everyday essentials, especially popular with nearby residents.

Restaurants

Dining on Harbour Island is a highlight of local life. It’s laid-back yet refined, with menus that celebrate Bahamian flavours and fresh seafood.

• Rooster Tail Bar & Grill: A lively waterfront spot at Valentine’s Resort offering creative bistro dishes, signature cocktails, and gorgeous ocean views. valentinesresort.com

• The Dunmore: An elegant restaurant within The Dunmore Hotel, known for its polished service, island-inspired cuisine, and sophisticated setting.

• Rock House: A stylish dining destination serving upscale fare in a relaxed yet romantic ambience, popular for both visitors and homeowners.

• Malcolm 51: Located at Pink Sands Resort, this chic spot blends island charm with gourmet dining, perfect for a night out or special occasion.

• Beyond the Reef: A casual, toes-in-the-sand beachfront eatery where you’ll find grilled favourites and laid-back island vibes.

Wellness and Boutique Fitness

Harbour Island’s approach to wellness is laid-back. Longstanding spots like the Harbour Island Spa offer personalised treatments and a loyal following, while resorts like The Dunmore feature elegant fitness spaces with high-end equipment. For those looking to stay active, Conch & Coconut organises yoga sessions, personal training, and even tennis, all tailored to the island’s relaxed but health-conscious vibe.

Marinas and Boating Access

Boating is a way of life on Harbour Island. The island has several small docks and marina facilities that cater to both locals and seasonal residents. Many homes have private docks, but the harbour itself is sheltered and ideal for keeping boats safely moored. 

Beaches and Shoreline

The beaches on Harbour Island are world-renowned, especially the iconic Pink Sands Beach, where powder-soft pink sand meets the gentle turquoise sea. The coastline is walkable and pristine, featuring calm waters ideal for swimming, snorkelling, and paddleboarding. You’re never far from a breathtaking view or a peaceful stretch of shoreline.