Eleuthera, Bahamas Real Estate

Homes for Sale and Rent in One of The Bahamas’ Most Peaceful and Scenic Family Islands

• All Listings
• Under $100,000
• $100,000 - $200,000
• $200,000 - $300,000
• $300,000 - $400,000
• $400,000 - $500,000
• $500,000 - $600,000
• $600,000 - $700,000
• $700,000 - $800,000
• $800,000 - $900,000
• $900,000 - $1,000,000
• Over $1,000,000

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Price Range

Save Search

Sort by:

Price, high to low

$48,000,000

Leru. / Leraux Cay, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 4,573,800 SqFt Residential MLS® # 68074

$39,500,000

Crown Pigeon Island & Cay, Eleuthera

15 Beds 15 Baths 479,160 SqFt Residential MLS® # 66706

$29,000,000

Islandia 466 Acres, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 20,298,960 SqFt Residential MLS® # 62757

$19,650,000

Gun Point & Ridley Head, Eleuthera

6 Beds 6 Baths 3,484,800 SqFt Residential MLS® # 53999

$19,000,000

Samuel Sands Tract, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 14,065,088 SqFt Residential MLS® # 63842

$18,000,000

Rock Sound Eleuthera, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt Commercial MLS® # 64219

$17,950,000

Buttonwood Estate, Eleuthera

5 Beds 6 Baths 23,235 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67764

$17,500,000

La Palmeraie Villa 1, Eleuthera

9 Beds 9 Baths 11,736 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67584

$16,950,000

Harbour Island Beachfront, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 140,133 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67375

$16,000,000

Sky Beach Resort, Eleuthera

19 Beds 19 Baths 10,000 SqFt Residential MLS® # 65809

$14,950,000

Sand Bank Beach Villa, Eleuthera

6 Beds 6 Baths 4,680 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67900

$12,350,000

East Russell Island, Eleuthera

0 Beds 0 Baths 717,869 SqFt Residential MLS® # 67514

1 2 3 4 28

Next

Discover Life in Eleuthera

Eleuthera is one of those places where time slows down and nature takes the lead. The island stretches long and it’s lined with pink-sand beaches, limestone cliffs, and peaceful coves. It’s usually uncrowded and an ideal home for someone who wishes to slow down and connect with nature. The crystal clear waters are calm and perfect for kayaking or paddleboarding, and there are plenty of hidden trails to explore. In Eleuthera, you can settle into a lifestyle that’s as relaxed as the island itself.

What makes Eleuthera stand out:

• Quiet beaches with soft pink sand and wide open space

• Naturally beautiful landscapes with cliffs, blue holes, and lush greenery

• Calm, clear waters ideal for boating, snorkelling, and paddleboarding

• Low population density and plenty of room to build or spread out

• Friendly, down-to-earth communities that value privacy and connection

• Slower pace of life with a strong sense of independence

• Excellent potential for off-grid living, farming, or investment land

Eleuthera Real Estate Market: Homes for Sale and Rent

Eleuthera’s real estate market offers both variety and value. Buyers are drawn here for its space, serenity, and scenery. The real estate market appeals to a wide range of people with one thing common: they’re all looking for something a little more off the beaten path.

Homes here tend to hold their value well. Interest is especially strong in properties with water access or development potential. You can find everything from modest homes to luxury beachfront estates available, and development is in full swing.

• Average Sale Price: $1,075,481.48

• Median Sale Price: $690,000

• Price Range: $140,000 - 5,250,000 

• Property Types: Single and Multi-Family Homes, Luxury Homes, Beachfront Homes, Harbourfront Homes, Vacation Homes

• Market Vibe: Quietly competitive with rapid development

Single Family and Multi-Family Homes

Eleuthera offers a wide variety of housing options, from modest single-family cottages to larger multi-unit homes suited for extended families, rental use and affordability. Some are move-in ready, while others offer the chance to renovate or build over time. Whichever kind of housing option you’re looking for, there’s no shortage of choice in Eleuthera.

Waterfront Homes

Waterfront properties in Eleuthera are some of the most sought-after. Whether you’re drawn to the open views of the ocean or the calm shelter of a harbourfront setting, these homes offer front-row access to the island’s natural beauty. Many estates have private access to beaches, and you will also find traditional island homes with direct boat access. 

Rentals in Eleuthera

Rental opportunities in Eleuthera are limited, but that’s precisely what makes them attractive. With relatively few homes coming onto the market each year, rental properties here tend to stay listed a bit longer, but they also draw consistent interest from long-term renters, digital nomads, and future buyers looking to experience the island before committing to a purchase.

For investors, this means less turnover but a steady, dependable stream of interest. And for buyers on the fence, renting is a great way to understand the rhythms of island life before choosing the right spot to call home.

• Average Rental Price: $3,275

• Median Rental Price: $2,650

• Rental Price Range: $1,800 – 6,000

• Typical Rental Appeal: Short- and long-term rentals based on the community

Everything You Need, Minutes Away

Eleuthera may feel off-the-grid, but life here is surprisingly convenient. Schools, markets, and great local eats are all within a short drive, and you’re connected by three airports along the island—North Eleuthera, Governor’s Harbour, and Rock Sound—making travel and access easy and dependable. Life here has a rural charm, but not at the expense of everyday essentials.

Schools

Families in Eleuthera have access to a range of respected schools, including experiential and public options that cater to different philosophies and age groups.

• The Island School: A unique secondary school focused on experiential learning and marine science, set on its own sustainable campus. Students from around the world gather here for transformative semesters.
  

• Windermere High School: A long-standing Christian high school serving grades 7–12, known for its values-based education and strong community roots.
  

• Preston H. Albury High School: A public high school serving students in and around Rock Sound, offering standard secondary education for residents on the island’s south end.
  

• North Eleuthera (Laura L. Anderson) Primary: The local public primary school, originally known as North Eleuthera Primary, renamed in honour of a dedicated lifelong educator.

Grocery Stores

Eleuthera has no big-box supermarkets, but its local grocery stores are well-curated and highly regarded by the community.

• Midway Cost Cutter (Savannah Sound): A clean, well-stocked convenience store known for reasonable prices and unexpected local items.
  

• Market Place (Rock Sound): One of the island’s largest grocers, offering a broad selection of produce, snacks, and essentials, frequently praised by residents for quality and variety.
  

• North Eleuthera Shopping Centre: A community grocery hub with a generous footprint, known for its own butcher counter and helpful service.
  

• Eleuthera Supply (Governor’s Harbour): A go-to convenience store offering produce, frozen goods, household items, and a few local specialities right on Queens Highway.

Restaurants

Dining in Eleuthera is about fresh flavours, casual settings, and ocean vibes that feel homey and local.

• Seaside Breeze (Tarpum Bay): A beachside spot serving fresh seafood and conch salad with ocean views and a friendly, relaxed bar setting.
  

• Sammy’s: A much-loved local eatery, known among residents for its hearty island-style meals and welcoming vibe.
  

• Pascal’s Oceanfront Restaurant: A casual oceanfront dining option where island flavours and sea views come together in a simple, unhurried setting.
  

Marinas and Boating Access

Eleuthera isn’t known for mega-marinas, but it offers strong boating access via working small harbours and yacht-friendly ports. From Governor’s Harbour to Current Island and Rock Sound, you’ll find suitable waters and facilities for both new and seasoned boaters. Launch points are thoughtfully positioned to make access to remote reefs, hidden coves, and neighbouring Family Islands quicker. 

Beaches and Shoreline

The romantic coastlines of Eleuthera feel untouched and always within reach. Think wide swaths of pink sand, limestone outcrops, and secret snorkelling spots. You can explore blue holes and historic caves like Preacher’s Cave, or behold the dramatic Glass Window Bridge; Eleuthera delivers beauty at every turn. It’s a natural playground for residents who prefer landscapes over crowds, and the ocean is an integral part of daily life.